Talking About HV Shunt Reactor Switching (part 1)

Talking About HV Shunt Reactor Switching (photo by Zaporozhtransformator Joint Stock Company - ZTR)

Content

Scope
Shunt reactors application
Closing operation
Opening operation (in next part)
Conclusions (in next part)

Scope

These notes aim to give basic idea of the main criticalities related to HV shunt reactorswitching, particularly in terms of voltage, and how such problems are faced and solved by modern switching technology.

Go to Content ↑

Shunt reactors application

Three-phase shunt reactors are basically aimed to compensate excess of reactive power generation so preventing unacceptable voltage rise and power losses.

Lightly loaded¹, long power transmission lines over 220kV, or cables 100kV and higher, are capacitive loads causing voltage increase because of the line charging currents flowing through the line / cable self inductance (Ferranti effect).

In this cases the reactor is switched on and off during the day depending on the load, only. In fact, due to the need of reactive power consumption for voltage control and electrical system safety, the shunt reactor should be never tripped: in case of reactor fault, the whole line is tripped.

¹ As a reference value, it should be considered as “light” a load less than 70% of the surge impedance loading (SIL). For instance, a 345kV line with surge impedence 350Ω has about 345²/350 = 340MW SIL.

That is consistent with the fact that in some EHV lines permanently under-loaded, fixed reactors are installed (provided just with a disconnecting switch in presence of redundant shunt reactors, for maintenance purposes).

Another example of shunt reactor application is in presence of filter banks acting as capacitors at power frequency: that is the typical situation of HVDC converter station. HVDC converters produce harmonic distortion that need proper filter design to avoid heavy impact on network power quality.

Different combination of filters could be are foreseen in different load conditions to get the target value of THD. At the same time filters’ capacitor banks act also as a reactive power source providing the needed Mvar to the converter, which is an important inductive load.

Sometimes it could happen that specific combinations of converter load and filters configuration can satisfy the harmonic constraints, but lead to the reactive power generated by filters exceeding that consumed by converter over acceptable level: in that situations a shunt reactor is used.

The configuration of shunt reactors may be various (bank of single-phase reactors, three-phase unit with a 3- or 5-legged core, etc.) , but following considerations still remain valid.

It is to be noted that shunt reactor is, by definition, a reactor directly connected to the network; in some applications reactors are applied through a transformer (e.g. connected to tertiary winding); in both cases the principle is the same and the reactor acts as alinear inductance² , but this paper refers to the first.

On the other hand, despite the different possible earthing methods (isolated, solidly earthed or earthed through neutral reactor), solidly earthed three-phase shunt reactors will be considered.

² In case of iron core reactors, linearity is obtained with integrated air gaps.

Go to Content ↑

Closing operation

For what concerns the closing operation, the shunt reactor can be simply modeled as an inductance in series with a resistance. The latter is always present, despite the effort to minimize losses.

Shunt reactor closing operation scheme

Energy stored in the inductor before circuit breaker closing is zero, and network voltage is:

The current flowing in the circuit is then:

Where:

The way to cancel the transient term is to close the circuit breaker when the steady state component of current is zero (γ = φ). More simply, suppose and resistive part of the reactor impedance be zero (φ = 90°): the transient part of current is zero if the circuit breaker is switched on when the voltage
reaches its maximum value (γ = 90°).

On the contrary, the transient term will be maximum if the circuit breaker closes with γ = φ ±90°. In the simplified example that means γ = 0.

As the two terms (transient and steady state) sum each other, half a cycle later, when they have the same sign, the current increases over the steady state maximum value. The actual value depends on the circuit damping. Very low damping circuits (it is almost the case of shunt reactors) can see a current doubled, compared with the steady state.

In three phase circuits, with three-pole operated circuit breakers it is quite easy to meet a critical closing instant on at least one phase.

Because of above mentioned asymmetry in the transient current trend, closing operation can also generate zero sequence currents.

Despite of the linear design of shunt reactors, in case of their switching in at the worst instant (phase voltage equal to zero), the flux will increase with the voltage-time-area during the first half-cycle to a value twice the maximum flux in normal operation.

The current is proportional to the flux density, until reactor core saturation occurs. Above the point of saturation the current will increase faster than the flux. Saturation will be present in different amount in the three phases, because of the three-phases voltage 120° displacement.

That means the sum of DC components in the three phase currents will not be null, so producing a zero sequence current which could lead to nuisance tripping by protections.

The way to mitigate the high inrush currents and generally, the switching transients, due to random closing instants is to control the making instant for each pole of the circuit breaker. That means a single-pole operated circuit breaker is needed together with a Controlled Switching Device (CSD).

Several manufacturers offer their own models of CSD: basically the principle is the same and it is based on the measuring of voltage upstream the circuit breaker, on the source side.

In several cases a current feedback signal is used for adaptation control: as the switching times can be affected by temperature, auxiliary voltage variations, mechanical contingencies, etc. a deviation from target instant can occur. Such deviation is detected and properly taken into consideration during the next operation.

Go to Content ↑

Will be continued in 2 days… stay in tune.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

“Live Tank CB Application Guide” – ABB
“Buyers Guide HV Live Tank Circuit Breakers Ed5 en” – ABB
“Trasmissione e distribuzione dell’energia elettrica” – N. Faletti, P. Chizzolini
“Switching Shunt Reactors” – Roy W Alexander, NeilA. McCord P.E.
“HV shunt reactor secrets for protection engineers”- Zoran Gajić, Birger Hillström, Fahrudin Mekić

for your philippine electrical concerns...needs...installation...orders...safeelectrical2013@gmail.com

METRO MANILA PHILIPPINES

WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN METRO MANILA

WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN QUEZON CITY

ELECTRICAL WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN MAKATI PHILIPPINES

ELECTRICAL WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN TAGUIG PHILIPPINES

ELECTRICAL WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN MAKATI PHILIPPINES

ELECTRICAL WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN GLOBAL CITY PHILIPPINES

ELECTRICAL WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN MAKATI PHILIPPINES

ELECTRICAL WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN TAGUIG PHILIPPINES

ELECTRICAL WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN ALABANG PHILIPPINES

ELECTRICAL WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN GLOBAL CITY PHILIPPINES

WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN LUZON

WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN VISAYA

WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN SUBIC

WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN CLARK

WIRE AND CABLE SUPPLIER IN THE PHILIPPINES

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN METRO MANILA

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN QUEZON CITY

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN LUZON

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN VISAYA

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN SUBIC

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN CLARK

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINE INDUSTRIAL PARK

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINE ECONOMIC ZONE

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER FOR PHILIPPINE FOREIGNERS

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER FOR PHILIPPINE PROVINCES

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES BATANES

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES LAOAG

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES CLARK

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES SUBIC

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES MANILA

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES BATANGAS

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES LEGASPI

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES BORACAY

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES PALAWAN

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES PUERTO PRINCESA

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES ILOILO

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES BICOL

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES CEBU

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES BOHOL

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES SURIGAO

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES DUMAGUETE

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES BACOLOD

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES CAGAYAN DE ORO

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES SURIGAO

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES BUKIDNON

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES ILIGAN

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES ZAMBOANGA

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES BUTUAN

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES GENERAL SANTOS

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES ZAMBOANGA

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES DAVAO

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES CAGAYAN DE ORO

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN PHILIPPINES BINONDO

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN MAKATI PHILIPPINES

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN TAGUIG PHILIPPINES

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN METRO MANILA PHILIPPINES

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN MANILA PHILIPPINES

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN NOVALICHES QUEZON CITY PHILIPPINES

ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER IN SAN JOSE DEL MONTE BULACAN PHILIPPINES

FOR YOUR PHILIPPINE ELECTRICAL CONCERNS...NEEDS...INSTALLATION...QUOTATION...ORDERS

KINDLY EMAIL US: SAFEELECTRICAL2013@GMAIL.COM

SAFEELECTRICALONLINE@GMAIL.COM

FOR YOUR PHILIPPINE ELECTRICAL CONCERNS...NEEDS...INSTALLATION...QUOTATION...ORDERS:

KINDLY EMAIL US: SAFEELECTRICAL2013@GMAIL.COM

SAFEELECTRICALONLINE@GMAIL.COM

FOR PHILIPPINE INQUIRIES LIKE LIGHTNING ARRESTER SUPPLY AND INSTALLATION

MOBILE NUMBERS: SMART: +63 09079522099

+63 09214026477

GLOBE: +63 09273919600

+63 09157920129

SUN: +63 9227192434

+63 09336253505

WIRELESS LANDLINE: +63 4068727

+63 4922566

LANDLINE: +63 4317553

HURRY..CALL US...NOW!!!!

THANK YOU FOR YOUR ORDERS AND INQUIRIES...

LIGHTNING ARRESTER SUPPLIER AND INSTALLER IN THE PHILIPPINES

ELECTRICAL FENCE SUPPLIER AND INSTALLER IN THE PHILIPPINES

LIGHTNING ARRESTER SUPPLIER AND INSTALLER IN METRO MANILA

ELECTRICAL FENCE SUPPLIER AND INSTALLER IN METRO MANILA

LIGHTNING ARRESTER SUPPLIER AND INSTALLER IN THE PHILIPPINE ECONOMIC ZONE

ELECTRICAL FENCE SUPPLIER AND INSTALLER IN THE PHILIPPINE ECONOMIC ZONE

LIGHTNING ARRESTER SUPPLIER AND INSTALLER IN THE VISAYA REGION

ELECTRICAL FENCE SUPPLIER AND INSTALLER IN THE VISAYAS REGION

LIGHTNING ARRESTER SUPPLIER AND INSTALLER IN THE MINDANAO

ELECTRICAL FENCE SUPPLIER AND INSTALLER IN THE MINDANAO

FOR YOUR LIGHTNING STRIKE PROTECTION...LET US HELP YOU AVOID SUCH ACCIDENTS...

BEFORE IT IS TOO LATE...BEFORE IT IS TOO LATE...

WHEN LIGHTNING STRIKE HIT YOU..

I GUARANTEE YOU..YOU'LL NEVER LIVE TO TELL YOUR EXPERIENCE...

DON'T BE THE NEXT VICTIM...PROTECT YOURSELF..YOUR FAMILY..YOUR BUSINESS AT ALL TIMES..

INSTALL A LIGHTNING ARRESTER IN YOUR PLACE...DO IT NOW BEFORE YOUR CAUGHT UNAWARE...

IF YOU HAVE LIGHTING PROTECTION INSTALLED...

YOU'LL HAVE PEACE OF MIND...YOU CAN SLEEP WELL EVEN WHEN LIGHTNING STRIKES...

YOU KNOW YOUR WELL PROTECTED...

IN YOUR HOME, IN YOUR PLACE OF BUSINESS AND IN YOUR PROPERTIES...

HURRY..CALL US...NOW!!!!

THANK YOU FOR YOUR ADVANCE ORDERS AND INQUIRIES...

"PHILIPPINE FOREIGNERS AND PHILIPPINE PROVINCES ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER

AND SERVICE PROVIDER"

"SAFE ELECTRICAL SUPPLY AND SERVICES"

Jigz Enerio - Sales/Project Coordinator

Safe Electrical Supply and Services

Registered Master Electrician PRC#00034433

Real Estate Broker PRC#0000838

Institute of Integrated Electrical Engineers(IIEE)Membership#19420

Telephone: 4068727 4922566

Telefax: 4178583 4317553

smart: 09079522099

globe: 09273919600

sun: 09227192434

Building K-415 Smilecitihomes 1 Barangay Kaligayahan

Novaliches Quezon City 1124

YAHOO MESSENGER: SAFEELECTRICALSUPPLYANDSERVICES@YAHOO.COM

SAFEELECTRICALSUPPLYANDSERVICES

WEBSITE: WWW.SAFEELECTRICALSUPPLYANDSERVICES.BLOGSPOT.COM

"The Elevator to Success is always out of order,

but one can always use the stairs"

"One does not Lead by hitting people over the Head,

that's assault not Leadership" - Eisenhower

"If You Think Education is Expensive,

count the cost of being ignorant" - Past Harvard President

"If you're gonna be thinking anyway,

you might as well think big" - Donald Trump

"Insanity, doing the same things

over and over again,

then expecting a different result" - Albert Einstein

"Small minds talk of people,

average minds talk of events,

great minds talk of ideas"

“I shall pass this way but once; any good that I can do

or any kindness I can show to any human being;

let me do it now. Let me not defer nor neglect it,

for I shall not pass this way again.”

Etienne de Grellet (1773-1855);

Quaker missionary

If you wanna make the world a better place

take a look at yourself and make a change

- Michael Jackson

"The Best things in life are FREE,

Family, Relatives, Friends, Health and most especially Time"

Our company operates in the principle of cooperation, collaboration,

joint partnership/marketing and cross promotion.

We treat our people,clients,suppliers,affiliates

subcontractors, business owners, entrepreneurs(SMALL TIME or Bigtime),

common people,sales people especially PURCHASING OFFICERS as our business partners and friends.

We operate in the principle of Win-Win in every transactions we get involved in

and our company would like to establish good long-term relationship with the client we serve...

We value and aim for REPEAT BUSINESS...and not just for a one-time transaction...

Delivery Schedule: 9am to 10pm Monday to Friday Only

OFFICE DAYS: Monday to Friday Only

9-12PM TO 1-5PM ONLY

Saturday: Lord's day "EL SHADDAI" The God who is more than enough

Sunday: Family day

10% of what the company earns, we give to the Lord,

10% of what the company earns, we give to charity,

this is the company's way of giving back part of what it earns,

to the community and above.

"It is unwise to pay too much, but it's worst to pay too little.

When you pay too much, you lose a little money - that is all...

When you pay too little, You sometimes lose everything,

Because the thing you bought or the service you acquired

was incapable of doing the thing it was bought or intended to do.

The common law of business balance

prohibits paying a little and getting a lot - it can't be done.

If you deal with the lowest bidder,

It is well to add something for the risk you run,

And if you do that,

You will have enough to pay for something better."

- JOHN RUSKIN(1819 - 1900)

"Good things aren't cheap,

and cheap things aren't good"

HEALTH TIPS HEALTH TIPS HEALTH TIPS HEALTH TIPS HEALTH TIPS HEALTH TIPS

ATTENTION: FOR ALL INDIVIDUALS ESPECIALLY THOSE AGE 40 AND ABOVE.

MEDICAL EXPERIMENT - MIRACLES WITH WATER

Japanese Sickness Association has published the following experiment with WATER.

They Claim 100% success for curing old and new diseases as follows:

1. Headache, BP, Anaemia, Arthrosis, Paralysis, Palpitation, Epilepsy and Obesity

2. Cough, Bronchitis, Asthma, and Tuberculosis

3. Meningitis and any other diseases connected with URINE and LIVER.

4. Hyper-acidity, Gastritis, Dysentery, Constipation, Piles and Diabetes

5. Any other diseases connected with Eye, Nose and Throat.

6. Irregular menstrual periods of women

METHOD OF TREATMENT AND MAINTENANCE:

1. Wake-up early morning and drink Four(4) glasses (160ml each) in an empty stomach.

Thereafter, no solids or liquids should be taken up to 45 minutes.

2. Normal breakfast can be taken after the 45 minutes time elapsed.

3. Nothing either liquid or solid should be taken for Two(2) hours after breakfast, the same as with Lunch and Dinner.

4. After Dinner nothing should be taken before bedtime or sleep.

Sick and old people will find it difficult to drink Four(4) glasses of water at an instant in the beginning, but, can increase

gradually to the recommended level in a short time period.

Experiment has proved that the following diseases have been cured on treatment of water for the period shown against them

a) Hypertension - 30 days d) Constipation - 10 days

b) Gastric Problems - 30 days e) Cancer - 6 months

c) Diabetes - 30 days f) Tuberculosis - 3 months

Those who suffering from Arthritis should try this experiment three(3) times a day for one(1) week and thereafter reduce to

once in the morning. For first few days you may experience to pass urine more than the norma, but no side effects.

THIS WILL CLEANSED YOUR BODY OF IMPURITIES AND WILL

PREVENT MANY TYPES OF DISEASES...

EXERCISE RELIGIOUSLY...

AS THE SAYING GOES "HEALTH IS WEALTH"

REMEMBER:

70% of our body is made up of water...

only 30% of our body is solid...

HEALTH IS WEALTH...

WHAT'S THE USE OF HAVING A BILLION

BUT LYING IN A BED - SICK

OR SUFFERING FROM AN ILLNESS.....

I WOULD RATHER HAVE A CLEAN BILL OF HEALTH FOR A BILLION.

WHEN YOU REACH THE AGE OF 35 EXERCISE IS A MUST...

WATCH YOUR DIET...

EXERCISE DAILY AND RELIGIOUSLY

TAKE YOUR MULTIVITAMINS TO SUPPLEMENT YOUR FOOD INTAKE....

THE BEST THINGS IN LIFE ARE FREE.....

FAMILY....RELATIVES....FRIENDS....HEALTH and most importantly TIME....

YOU ARE MORE BLESSED THAN OTHERS...

WHEN YOU HAVE BOTH YOUR EYES SO YOU CAN CLEARLY SEE

OTHERS HAVE ONLY ONE...OTHERS ARE TOTALLY BLIND...

WHEN YOU HAVE BOTH YOUR EARS SO YOU CAN CLEARLY HEAR

OTHERS HAVE ONLY ONE...OTHERS ARE TOTALLY DEAF...

WHEN YOU HAVE BOTH YOUR HANDS SO YOU CAN HOLD THINGS WELL

OTHERS HAVE ONLY ONE...OTHERS HAVE NONE...

WHEN YOU HAVE BOTH YOUR FEET SO YOU CAN WALK EASILY

OTHERS HAVE ONE...OTHERS HAVE NONE..

WHEN YOU STILL HAVE YOUR PARENTS...

OTHERS HAVE ONE...OTHERS HAVE NONE...

WHEN YOU HAVE CHILDREN...

OTHERS HAVE ONE...OTHERS HAVE NONE...

WHEN YOU HAVE A FAMILY...

SOME HAVE NONE...OTHERS TOTALLY ORPHANED

WHEN YOU ARE LIVING IN THE PHILIPPINES...A DEMOCRATIC COUNTRY..

THE WEATHER NOT THAT EXTREMELY HOT NOR COLD..

WERE PLANTS AND TREES GROW EASILY

SURROUNDED BY SEAS FULL OF FISHES AND NATURAL RESOURCES

WHEN YOU ARE OLD AND STILL LIVING WITH YOUR CHILDREN

IN SOME COUNTRIES OLD PARENTS AND PEOPLE

ARE LEFT IN THE "HOME OF THE AGED NURSING FOUNDATION"

WHEN YOU STILL HAVE YOUR JOB...WORKING IN AN AIR-CONDITIONED

ROOM..JUST CONSIDER THE CONSTRUCTION WORKERS DOING THEIR

HARD LABOR JOBS UNDER THE HEAT OF THE SUN...IGNORING THE

DANGEROUS ELEMENTS CONFRONTING THEM....

COUNT YOUR BLESSINGS...COUNT THEM ONE BY ONE...

DON'T THINK OF SAYING ANY UNKIND WORD...

THINK OF PEOPLE WHO CAN'T SPEAK,

DON'T COMPLAIN ABOUT THE FOOD YOU EAT,

SOME HAVE NOTHING.

DON'T COMPLAIN ABOUT LIFE,

PAINT A SMILE ON YOUR FACE

AND THANK GOD YOU'RE ALIVE AND STILL AROUND

LIFE IS A GIFT......

LIVE IT WELL......

SAFETY 1ST

REPEAT BUSINESS 2ND

PRAY ALWAYS IT WORKS!!!

ATTENTION: FOREIGN ELECTRICAL MANUFACTURERS AND ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTORS

OUR COMPANY WELCOMES ELECTRICAL FOREIGN SUPPLIER/MANUFACTURER/S

WHO WOULD LIKE TO OFFER THEIR PRODUCT LINE

HERE IN THE PHILIPPINES BUT ON A CONSIGNMENT BASIS ONLY,

MEANING PAYMENT WILL BE FOR A CERTAIN PERIOD...EXAMPLE SIX(6) MONTHS TO ONE(1) YEAR,

ALL THOSE ITEMS THAT WILL NOT BE SOLD OR SLOW MOVING ITEMS WILL BE REPLACED

AND WE WILL JUST PAY FOR THOSE SOLD ITEMS

YOUR COMPANY WILL BE SHOULDERING THE FORWARDING/FREIGHT COST

OR SHIPMENT COST...

WE WILL BE IN CHARGE OF STOCKAGE,MARKETING,SALES AND AFTER SALES CONCERNS..

CONTACT,EMAIL OR CALL US IF YOUR COMPANY IS INTERESTED WITH OUR OFFER...

BY THE WAY PAYMENT WILL BE BANK TO BANK...

YOUR BANK WILL BE COORDINATING WITH OUR LOCAL BANK HERE IN THE PHILIPPINES....

CALL/EMAIL US IF YOUR COMPANY IS INTERESTED ON OUR OFFER....

"YOUR FRIENDLY PHILIPPINE FOREIGNERS AND PHILIPPINE PROVINCES ONLINE ELECTRICAL SUPPLIER"

Saturday, September 14, 2013